30 Comments
User's avatar
Zach's avatar

Criminally underrated record. The documentary was great and the songs get panned over way too much. No reason for this to be considered their worst record by many people. All of them kind of stand apart and on their own, so you really can't take it like you're listening to an album, but listening to a collection of songs. You're listening to a road trip through America.

Expand full comment
Karrin F's avatar

Agree-I LOVE this album and especially the series-I am baffled why people don’t love this more. And I really wish they would play more of these songs on tour.

Expand full comment
YeatusFajitus's avatar

This was a cracking album with some great guest appearances and the accompanying documentary was really interesting.

Expand full comment
Zach's avatar

I wonder what else was cracking during this album cycle...

Expand full comment
lyn's avatar

Bone cracking

Expand full comment
Doris Fran's avatar

Yeatus I’m always up for a fun conversation—text me! 💬 on WhatsApp

╋ 𝟰𝟰 (752) 941-9335

Expand full comment
D_Blizzie's avatar

The THRONE! Those were some great shows.

Expand full comment
Russell Loasby's avatar

Thought St Cecelia EP might get a mention for this era!

Expand full comment
Zach's avatar

They must have some kind of beef with it because they've only played Sean live and sound-checked The Never-ending Sigh once or twice. What a great EP though.

Expand full comment
LBEM's avatar

Remembering the Irving Plaza (NYC) riot/show. Only concert performance of ‘I am a River’ which was epic. And Dave scaling the balcony. Classic.

Expand full comment
Calm The MindlessChatter's avatar

I wanna get outside! Baby let’s get outside outside!!!! Of Me!! PLEASE 🙏🏾 This song hits me like sunlight on my skin….

Ahhhhh🌅

Expand full comment
Michael Boyd's avatar

Favourite track is Congregation 🤘❤️

Expand full comment
Tom Grant's avatar

Personally loved the live aspect of this album. Really enjoyed the series.

I Am a River healed me in so many ways I didn’t realise I needed it.

Expand full comment
Doris Fran's avatar

Tom I’m always up for a fun conversation—text me! 💬 on WhatsApp

╋ 𝟰𝟰 (752) 941-9335

Expand full comment
Sarah Anne Keenan's avatar

Perhaps my mostest favoritest!

🫶

Expand full comment
Chuck L's avatar

My favorite FF album, bar none…

Expand full comment
Zander Scot's avatar

Saw them play RFK in DC on July 4 for the 20th anniversary in support of this record. I was on the barrier.

It was the first show after Dave broke his leg, and the one where they unveiled The Throne. Before they went on, they'd dropped a curtain to hide the staging, and were playing all the Sonic Highways episodes (minus music) in order on the jumbotrons. But it was windy, and the curtain billowed up so that those of us in the very front could occasionally see what was going on.

When the roadies wheeled out The Throne, We went nuts, like "NO WAY!!!" Because the cryptic post they'd made a week or two before of a YouTube video of Gary Neumann playing "Down In The Park" live, where he drove around the stage in a futuristic car/throne, finally made sense.

"The Feast and the Famine" is probably one of the best Foo Fighters songs ever. Fight me.

Expand full comment
Marlo Eddy's avatar

Wow, I remember the first riffs of "something from nothing" I listened to. I bought the most fucking special bundle and don't regret. I was living far from home and listened a lot while I was driving. Totally underrated, and I think it's due to the masterpiece Wasting Light, cos' everyone wanted something similar and it wasn't. Saint Cecilia is an awesome EP as well.

Expand full comment
Thiago Messias Rodrigues's avatar

Respect ✊🏾🇧🇷

Expand full comment
David's avatar

This album came out my senior year of high school. It was all I could think about that whole year. I remember trying to beat the bots while in my stats class to see them in Nashville at the Ryman on Halloween. Sadly I didn’t have the opportunity but the series made with this album is an amazing piece of music journey and history that everyone should watch. Thankfully I was able to see them in Anaheim in October 2015 for an amazing show.

Expand full comment
Simon's avatar

Their last really good album. Sounded so different and fresh at the time (for example I am a River) and coincidentally the last time they worked with Butch Vig. Not sure why songs are so criminally underplayed in live shows - SFN, Congregation & Outside are some of their best work. Loved the series too.

Expand full comment
Doris Fran's avatar

Simon I’m always up for a fun conversation—text me! 💬 on WhatsApp

╋ 𝟰𝟰 (752) 941-9335

Expand full comment
mwhis5555's avatar

My first foo show was on the broken leg tour in KC. Got a great picture of Dave on his guitar throne, it has been the background on my phone since then!!

Expand full comment